First Presbyterian Church Douglasville is a Juicys Winner - Denominational Change

First Presbyterian Church Douglasville is a Juicys Winner - Denominational Change

Posted November 20, 2015 by Jerod Clark

(The Juicys are a way to recognize and reward those churches who’ve worked to improve their church communications during the last year.  It includes giving them a grant to jump start their next project. To see past winners, click here.)

The Project: Denominational Change

Guiding a church through denominational change is daunting. Yet after realizing their church’s biblical beliefs and denominational stances didn’t match, First Presbyterian Church in Douglasville, Georgia, knew it was a step they had to take.

Not only were they faced with keeping the 55-year-old congregation of 650 people united, they were also met with a challenging process for leaving including raising nearly a half million dollars to keep their building.

“This type of change has split some congregations, but leadership knew that we wanted our church family to remain together,” explains Elder Melanie Gibbs. “We trusted God’s guidance and launched our ‘Together’ communications campaign.”


The Process

The old denomination’s process called for 80% of the congregation to vote for the change. Yet, FPCD leadership couldn’t imagine losing 20% of people they cared about, so they set the goal of getting 95% agreement.

While there were many tactical pieces that needed work, FPCD first spent time creating foundational strategy.

“Although there were specific outcomes we hoped to achieve, our central goal was to navigate this difficult process in a way that honored Christ and kept our congregation intact,” says Melanie. “In every decision, we returned to those fundamentals to see if our plans served the goal. We tried to convey to members that we did not expect every member to agree on all things, but they were valued as part of our church family. With the cross as the focus of the ‘Together’ logo, we hoped all would be reminded that Christ should be central to everything we as Christians do; although we may differ on some points, we are unified in Him.”

The denominational separation process was going to be long, with lots of moving pieces. FPCD decided to develop multiple communications teams to handle various stages of the process so that people had a manageable workload. Also, understanding that different members process messages in different ways, FPCD used a variety of means to communicate with members.

Melanie says, “In addition to the direct mail pieces, the team also had several signs made. We printed ‘Together’ stickers that many members seemed to enjoy wearing to show their support. We held some information sessions -- congregation-wide and with small groups. We published information in our church newsletter and bulletin inserts. We made leaders available between services to answer questions. And we posted some information on our church website, all in an effort to meet members where they were.”

Another important piece of the campaign was in-person and printed testimonies. Hearing from fellow members, instead of only church leaders, made others more comfortable with the process.

Finally, FPCD had a “Shepherding Team” who made an effort to reach out to each member in person during the process to make sure even those on the fringe felt like they were involved.

In the end, 95.5% of the congregation voted for the change.


What We Liked

When it comes to major changes like denominational affiliation, it can often lead to church splits or even closure. FPCD leaned in to their belief God was calling for them to change and built a process that was thorough, intentional, personal, inclusive and cohesive. Not only did the campaign develop unity, but it’s also making the church more noticeable in their community. New people are coming -- helping FPCD thrive and not just survive.


Up Next

In February, FPCD will host “Night to Shine” -- a prom night experience, centered on God’s love, for people with special needs 16 and older. It will be a true red carpet experience with limos, photos, catered food, a DJ, decorations and more.

“This is a significant opportunity to share God’s love with our community, particularly a segment of the population who may not regularly hear that they are valued, plus their families, who may not often have the chance to see their children celebrated,” says Melanie. “We would like to make our guests truly feel they are precious and loved. We hope to build long-term relationships with some individuals who may need a church family to walk alongside them.”

Filed under: Branding, Mission and Vision, Church Juice, The Juicys, Communications, Leadership

About the Author

Jerod Clark

Jerod joined ReFrame Media in 2007 and built Church Juice from scratch. He poured all his passion for branding, marketing, and messaging into the ministry, publishing e-books, blog posts, and speaking at conferences to help churches energize their communications. He also served as ReFrame’s in-house graphic designer. Before beginning his work at Church Juice, Jerod was a local TV news reporter. In 2016, Jerod stepped away from the ministry to pursue interests in marketing and communications on new horizons.

Don't miss a post

Join our email list

Comments (1)

  • Chris Price
    7:12 PM
    Mon, Nov 28, 2016

    Lol. They changed presbyterian groups, not denominations. The congregation was dismissed from the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and it joined a, then, new denomination called ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians. If is not like the went Lutheran, Baptist, Assembly of God or Church of Christ.

Leave a Comment

Share your thoughts about this blog post with us.
All fields are required.

Recent Posts

How to Have Better Announcements by Sunday
How to Have Better Announcements by Sunday

Posted August 14, 2018 by Joel Schaap

It is possible to pull off great announcements this weekend, and a great way to start is by avoiding these five common potholes.
Before You Ditch The Paper Bulletin Consider This
Before You Ditch The Paper Bulletin Consider This

Posted August 9, 2018 by Jeanette Yates

Paper bulletins serve a purpose and can actually help your digital strategy.
Church Bulletins are Awful
Church Bulletins are Awful

Posted August 7, 2018 by Ernesto Alaniz

Church bulletins are a drain on resources, an ineffective way to communicate, and a obstacle to gospel mission.
Is the Church Bulletin a Sacred Cow?
Is the Church Bulletin a Sacred Cow?

Posted August 2, 2018 by Bryan Haley

What role does your church bulletin play in the church’s overall communication strategy? Do we have the bulletin because that’s how it’s always been, or can it be an effective communication tool?
3 Things to Do Each Week In Your Communications
3 Things to Do Each Week In Your Communications

Posted July 24, 2018 by Carrie Evans

Here are three basic elements that church communicators should include every week in their communication plan.
Marketing Is Not a Bad Word
Marketing Is Not a Bad Word

Posted July 19, 2018 by Chris Hunt

Words like marketing sometimes turnoff pastors, elders, and board members. Isn’t marketing a business term? What does marketing have to do with church? Marketing is not a bad word. Marketing is about making a straight path so that your ministry happens.
I Notcied a Typo inn the Bullitin: Let’s Talk About Making Mistakes
I Notcied a Typo inn the Bullitin: Let’s Talk About Making Mistakes

Posted July 10, 2018 by Dave Hartwell

As church communicators, our work is out in the open: we write web copy, bulletin announcements, social media posts, and mass emails. Every once in a while, we make a mistake. Mistakes are inevitable; how we deal with them isn't.
Juicy Website Winner 2018: Hope Church NYC
Juicy Website Winner 2018: Hope Church NYC

Posted July 4, 2018 by Bryan Haley

Hope Church in New York City is The Juicys’ 2018 winner for the website category. Here’s what makes Hope’s website great.
The Power of Facebook Events
The Power of Facebook Events

Posted June 25, 2018 by Ernesto Alaniz

Facebook events are a cheap and easy way to get your church’s event in front of your entire community.
6 Social Media Tips for Your Church
6 Social Media Tips for Your Church

Posted June 21, 2018 by Bryan Haley

Social media is a great tool that churches can use to build and expand relationships, as well as a tool for outreach. Here are six tips to help your church utilize social media better.